新手上路
四星級會員
- 舊站積分
- 110
- 舊站發表文章數
- 1862
|
引用diyaudio Keith Taylor
I must confess that discussions on the audibility of different capacitor types in audio systems do not hold a lot of interest for me because differences of statistical significance have not been shown in properly conducted tests, that I am aware of. It was therefore a bit surprising to see mention in a recent AES Journal (Audio Eng' Soc') of a paper to be presented on the subject of mechanical resonances in capacitors in audio applications. I imagined it was refering to microphony due to external vibration and did not think much more about it.
A few days ago I received the May issue of Electronics World, which, sadly is not what it used to be re articles on audio. But, lo and behold, there is an article on capacitors for audio by Paul Dodds, Senior engineer at Clarity Cap. The central thesis of the article is mechanical resonances; but not due to microphony from external vibration, but, rather, internal mechanical resonances between the layers of film and metal foil.
With an applied voltage, irrespective of polarity, adjacent layers of the metal foil are attracted thus compressing the dialectric. It is this effect that can excite mechanical resonances in the foil/film. The resonance is excited at twice the frequency of an applied AC signal because the positive half cycle causes attraction between layers, as does the negative half cycle. These resonances are said to lie in the range 5 to 25KHz, presumably meaning 5KHz to 25KHz.
Having identified a distortion? mechanism the company engaged the University of Salford to conduct listening tests on supplied samples of capacitors including low resonance types. In the presence of proper blind test protocols the low resonance types generated a 70 percent preference rating. Preferences for "spatial information" and "clarity" also produced winning scores. So what does it all mean? From some rather poorly described plots it seems the resonances are quite high Q, meaning that if you were to play music in certain keys you may never hear them! For applications such as ordinary coupling capacitors the capacitance value is going to be changed at an audio rate at certain discrete frequencies raising the question; are we talking about a linear distortion or a non linear distortion or maybe neither.
所以電容會震動 會吃細節
電壓居然會造成震動 |
|